Three years after the crash that killed 15-year-old Aiden Lutz the man responsible was sentenced Monday morning closing a three-year legal battle.
On October 19, 2023 Lutz was riding his e-bike along Dutchtown Road when he was hit and killed by 41-year-old Joshua Rivera. Rivera fled the scene but was arrested days later and charged in Lutz death.
The trial for the case was set to begin yesterday morning but was canceled after a plea agreement was reached late last week. Monday morning Rivera was sentenced Rivera to 10 to 24 years in prison.
During the victim impact statement Lutz’s mother Tara called Aiden “the kind of kid you want your kids to be friends with.”
Aiden was a boy scout and was called a role model by follow scout and friend Ryan Orsborn. He said Aiden was “always cheerful and smiling” and “someone the younger scouts looked up to.”
Tara also said Aiden’s death “left a gaping hole so large it takes my breath away.” Also saying “life will never be as carefree as it once was” because of Rivera.
Aiden’s father Ben he feels guilt “doing the things Aiden liked and guilt going on family vacations.”
The two had planned on going to Volkswagen car shows with Aiden who was six months away from obtaining his own license.
Now Ben says he walks into Aiden’s room sees a “room that should be changing but instead it stays the same.”
Aiden’s sister did not speak at sentencing but did provide the courts with a sealed letter that was read by Judge James Arner privately from the bench.
After the family spoke Rivera was given the opportunity to speak as well.
He asked for forgiveness calling Aiden a great kid who had a great family and he thinks about Aiden every day. Filled with regret Rivera said admitted he was at total fault.
“I assure you I’m gonna become the best person I can because (Aiden) doesn’t have that time,” Rivera said as he finished speaking.
The district attorney’s office had originally charged Rivera with murder of the third degree which caused much of the delay to trial. The charge led to legal challenges from the defense that went to the state Superior Court.
The DA’s office intended to use evidence such as witness testimony of how fast Rivera was going at the time of the accident, a marijuana cigarette found in the vehicle three weeks after the accident, audio from police body camera footage that said Rivera’s vehicle smelled like “Cheech and Chong”, and a Facebook video posted by Rivera showing him driving at 130 mph.
The reason for wanting to purse all this evidence was to prove that when Rivera struck Lutz it was malice which is required by the state statute for the charge murder of the third-degree. Defense attorneys for Rivera appealed the use of all the evidence in effort to have the murder of third-degree charge dropped.
The Superior Court would have split decsions on the potential evidence. The court ruled a witness could testify to the speed in which Rivera was going, a marijuana cigarette in the car was permissible, audio on police body camera could not be played, and a Facebook video Rivera posted with a speedometer reading 130 mph could not be used in court.
Once the case returned to the Court of the Common Pleas, defense attorneys attempted to have Rivera released due to delays to his trial but that was denied. New witness testimony was also presented from Rivera’s ex-fiancé, who was with Rivera shortly after he hit Lutz.
But the final unknown was if the trial would be moved from Butler County to potentially Erie County due to a political flyer that was sent out to registered voters. The flyer mentioned Rivera’s past criminal record and could have potentially poisoned a jury pool.
Defense attorneys wanted to show potential jurors the flyer to see if they had received it but the DA argued that the flyer would poise any juror whether they received the flyer or not.
But less than a week before the trial began a plea agreement was reached. The charge of murder of the third degree was dropped and a guilty plea hearing was scheduled for last Thursday.
At the hearing Rivera pled guilty to three counts, accidents involving death of personal injury, accidents involving death or personal injury while not licensed, and homicide by vehicle.
For a total of 120 months to 288 months or 10 to 24 years with three years and just under a month of time served. Rivera will be 49 when he’s eligible for release in 2033 and if he is released will remain on parole for the remaining 14 years of his sentence.
Along with the prison time, Rivera will have to pay over $10,000 in fines, fees, restitution, and cost of prosecution. He is also not eligible for the state Recidivism Risk Reduction Incentive as per state law.
The post Judge Sentences Rivera In Death of Lutz appeared first on ButlerRadio.com – Butler, PA.





